400 have registered, despite obstacles


by Paul Komesaroff, Cameron Stewart, Camille La Brooy and Jennifer Philip,

One year of voluntary assisted dying in Victoria: 400 have registered, despite obstacles
Credit: Shutterstock

One year ago, the Victorian Voluntary Assisted Dying Act came into effect after a prolonged, intense and divisive public debate.

For some, it marked a major step forward for individual freedom in Victoria—an acknowledgement of the right of individuals to choose how they wished to live and die. For others, it signified a betrayal of some of the most fundamental moral precepts of our society and a reversal of the basic commitments of the medical profession.

A year later, what can we say about the impact of the legislation on Victorian life? We have been considering this question as part of our federally funded research project examining the impact and consequences of the Victorian Voluntary Assisted Dying legislation.

While it’s too soon to make a definitive judgement and it’s certainly not the case that the deep social wounds have healed, the Act appears to be functioning reasonably well, though some logistical and bureaucratic issues remain.

Meanwhile the coronavirus pandemic has complicated the picture as many patients seek advice on dying amid anxiety about contracting the disease.

How is it working?

The Act appears to be functioning tolerably well in that a series of “workable” arrangements have been put in place across a number of hospital and community settings. It’s not yet known how many Victorians have used the laws to end their lives. The number of people making inquiries (the first step along the way to assisted dying) was about 400 in this first year —double what had been anticipated.

But the Act has not opened the floodgates, unlike in Canada, where the number of people undertaking voluntary assisted dying were many times the anticipated number.

The system of “care navigators” to assist patients and their families to negotiate the complex bureaucratic processes has been working well. They have served as an important point of contact for patients, their family members and carers.

Given the difficulties of finding doctors who have signed up to do the assisted dying training, the navigators have established a network of participating and provided education across various health settings.

They have also supported clinicians through the difficulties of training and the existential realities of a changing role for medical professionals.

The process takes time

Inbuilt safeguards mean progressing through the procedural steps takes time. It isn’t possible to say if these are functioning effectively, or if they are too stringent or too lax. More data are needed from the participants in the scheme on their experiences of the procedure.

One year of voluntary assisted dying in Victoria: 400 have registered, despite obstacles
Some people have waited months for approval to access voluntary assisted dying laws. Credit: Shutterstock

There has been criticism of the bureaucratic requirements, which include a large amount of paperwork and multiple forms, taking weeks or even months to complete. Yet, some of these issues are inherent in the need for caution and there may be no way around them.

Ultimately, as the Parliament recognised from the beginning, a balance has to be struck between the right to access and the valid concerns of those who are more cautious.

Obstacles remain

Some logistical issues have arisen. There have been delays because of shortages of specialist doctors who have expressed willingness to participate and have completed the required training —especially in key specialties in some rural areas.

The responses of individual institutions have been variable. This was to be expected, because many were very clear about their opposition to voluntary assisted dying. Such services have sought to develop responses including involving broader health-care networks (such as those offered by care navigators) as patients have sought to exercise their rights under the law.

One issue yet to be resolved involves a law which prohibits using an electronic carriage service to “directly or indirectly counsel or incite” someone to end their life. Some have interpreted it to mean practitioners can’t use telehealth for assisted dying counselling. But we dispute whether this legislation can be applied to Victoria in our paper soon to be published in the Journal of Law and Medicine.

Another issue relates to a section of the laws which mean practitioners are only allowed to discuss assisted dying if the patient explicitly raises it. This safeguard exists to ensure coercion of patients doesn’t occur —including by health workers. But some have suggested it works as a barrier to full and open communication including sensitive exploration of an expressed wish to die. This clause has been omitted from the Western Australian legislation which was approved in December last year.

Coronavirus complications

The COVID-19 pandemic has complicated the picture as a number of patients have sought advice on dying amid anxiety about contracting the disease.

Anecdotal evidence suggests additional fear from the pandemic has increased demand for assisted dying services. But simultaneously, many are avoiding hospitals where many of the assisted dying assessments are occurring because of the fear of contracting COVID-19. The impact of the coronavirus means it is difficult to compare Victoria’s experience of assisted dying with other parts of the world (some of which implemented assisted dying long before the pandemic).

Overall, while not problem free, there have been no major obstacles to the functioning of the Act itself.

But none of this, of course, resolves the underlying ethical differences that have characterised the debates about assisted dying and euthanasia in Australia for decades. However, the uneasy compromise in Victoria has at least allowed the debate to move on and possibly has enhanced mutual respect for the two opposing sides.

It remains to be seen whether there will be a deep, fundamental shift in attitudes to death and dying, concepts of death, the care of elderly and vulnerable people, and the goals and purposes of medicine.

Our greatest protection against an undermining of key values, however, will lie in continuing open and articulate debates about these subjects, based on rigorously collected data. It is critical these debates continue.

Without more detail, it’s premature to say voluntary assisted dying laws are ‘working well’

Provided by
The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

One year of voluntary assisted dying in Victoria: 400 have registered, despite obstacles (2020, June 30)
retrieved 30 June 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-06-year-voluntary-dying-victoria-registered.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

Related posts:

Algeria welcomes remains of fighters against colonisation from France
Neurological symptoms described in children with COVID-19
United States: In Louisiana, Cajuns are keen to preserve their identity
HIV may not worsen COVID-19 outlook
250. Split-Lebertransplantation am UKR - Biermann Medizin
Live Coronavirus Updates: U.S. Leaders Change Course
EU authorises use of remdesivir to treat coronavirus
Turkey challenges allies and enemies alike in quest for ‘larger role on world stage’
Porres neuer Chefarzt in Leverkusen
Even gut immune response is site-specific
Systemische Therapie kann jetzt mit den Krankenkassen abgerechnet werden
Inflammatory Bowel Disease Tied to Increased Dementia Risk
Macron names Jean Castex as new French prime minister
Popular chemotherapy drug may be less effective in overweight and obese women
Studie: Junge Menschen rauchen und trinken weniger
Can an Algorithm Predict the Pandemic’s Next Moves?
Death toll climbs to more than 160 in Myanmar jade mine disaster
Israeli, UAE technology firms pen deal on virus research
Netanyahu's annexation plan, China's campaign against Uighurs and Hollywood before the censors
Uniklinik Köln: Augenheilkundliche Spezialbereiche jetzt in Deutschlands größtem Krebs-Ambulatorium
Dutch report new coronavirus infection on mink farm
Berufsverband will Weiterbildungsförderung auch für Urologen
French PM Édouard Philippe and his government resign as Macron prepares cabinet reshuffle
Florida under siege as pandemic accelerates
Japan asks US to extradite two men accused of helping ex-Nissan chief Ghosn escape
MB: EU-Ratspräsidentschaft als Chance für mehr Kooperation in Gesundheitsfragen nutzen
Monkeys infected with novel coronavirus developed short-term immunity
Das sichtbare Skelett 2.0 - Biermann Medizin
Peru surpasses 10,000 coronavirus deaths: health ministry
Herzreparatur mit der Gen-Schere - Biermann Medizin
UK to end quarantine for travelers from 'low-risk' countries
Turkish court opens trial of Saudi officials in killing of journalist Khashoggi
New study reveals how the brain organizes information about odors
French court to rule on reopening probe of former Rwandan president's assassination
Study could show why heart events increase seasonally
US Senate unanimously votes to approve draconian 'Hong Kong Autonomy Act'
US new single-day Covid-19 cases hit new worldwide record of over 55,000
Study says crowdsourced data could help map urban food deserts
Police in Europe arrest over 800 users of encrypted phone system used to plot crime
Artificial intelligence brings pancreatic cancer screening one step closer to reality
The Young Cut Loose in Myrtle Beach. The Virus Followed Them Home.
Study exposes disparities in health care access in rural Southern California
Florida State University Child Care Policy Draws Backlash
Surge in domestic child abuse during pandemic, reports specialist UK children's hospital
Live Coronavirus News: Updates and Video
Marijuana use while pregnant boosts risk of children's sleep problems
US sanctions against international court staff an act of ‘revenge’, says ICC’s Fatou Bensouda
New, more infectious strain of COVID-19 now dominates global cases of virus: study
‘We disinfect everything’: Amsterdam’s red-light district re-opens
France's Macron to embark on next phase of his presidency with ‘new team’
When Your Tween Is Bored
Why are more young people getting coronavirus?
Ideen-Wettbewerb: Woche des Sehens in Corona-Zeiten
French prosecutors seek trial for football star Karim Benzema over sextape scandal
Talking With Your Teen About Anti-Racism? Be Ready to Listen
COVID-19 death risk twice as high in New York City as some countries
Turkey demands apology from France over naval incident claim
CBM-Jahresbericht 2019: Mehr Geld für die Projektarbeit
Venezuela reverses decision to expel EU ambassador
How the body fights off urinary tract infections
Riechstörungen bei COVID-19: Was wissen Mediziner aktuell?
Did a Mutation Help the Coronavirus Spread? More Evidence, but Lingering Questions
Fear spreads through Hong Kong’s pro-democracy movement after security law imposed by China
Hot flushes and night sweats linked to 70% increase in cardiovascular disease
Niedriger Cortisolspiegel trägt dazu bei, dass wir altern
Epstein's ex-girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell arrested by FBI
Algerian court grants release of anti-government protest leader Karim Tabbou
Study reveals high prevalence of 'hidden' illnesses in people with type 2 diabetes
Heisenberg-Professur für Jennifer Andexer - Biermann Medizin
France to return remains of 24 fighters killed during colonisation of Algeria
CSIRO uses lab-grown 'lungs' to fight respiratory viruses
Krebsimmuntherapie bei Leukämie – Wie das körpereigene Abwehrsystem gestärkt werden kann
Australia Thought the Virus Was Under Control. It Found a Vulnerable Spot.
European Court of Human Rights condemns France over ‘inhuman’ living conditions for asylum-seekers
US virus cases smash daily record as global infections soar
Herzschwäche ist im Osten weitaus häufiger als im Westen
EU calls on Russia to probe 'irregularities' reported in vote granting Putin right to rule until 203...
Live Coronavirus Updates: U.S. Sets Case Record
Fires rage across Amazon rainforest, sparking fears of another disastrous summer season
Brazil surpasses 60,000 coronavirus deaths: official
Kabinett beschließt Nationale Demenzstrategie - Biermann Medizin
Closing bars to stop coronavirus spread is backed by science
Krankenhaus-Fallzahlen im SARS-CoV-2-Lockdown - Biermann Medizin
More than 100 dead in landslide at Myanmar jade mine
Novartis agrees to $642mn US settlement over kickbacks
Auf der Suche nach den Ursachen für männliche Unfruchtbarkeit
California takes step back from reopening amid virus surge
Neue Therapieoption bei schweren Infektionen, aber keine Belege für Überlegenheit
Researchers outline adapted health communications principles for the COVID-19 pandemic
Künstliche Intelligenz für die Medizintechnik
Health experts slam US for mass purchase of licensed Covid-19 drug
Travel safely with these expert tips in the age of coronavirus
Augenärzte wollen integrierte Notfallzentren ausbauen
US intelligence doubted Russia urged Taliban to kill US trips, says Trump
Why are patient and public voices absent in COVID-19 policy-making?
Neuer technischer Ansatz kann die Diagnose der pulmonalen Hypertonie verbessern
It Paid Doctors Kickbacks. Now, Novartis Will Pay a $678 Million Settlement.
Turkey to decide whether to redesignate iconic Hagia Sophia as mosque, not museum
Meeting recommended weekly physical activity levels linked to lower risk of death
Mississippi becomes final US state to remove Confederate symbol from flag

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

U.S. Commandos at Risk for Suicide: Is the Military Doing Enough?

Tue Jun 30 , 2020
“We started to realize that, while it might not even be the principal reason for suicides, this pressurized environment was having an impact,” said Joseph Votel, a retired Army general who commanded SOCOM from August 2014 to March 2016 and recalled discussions about the suicide study, but said he never […]