Doctors should be cautious when using current warning system for patient’s worsening health

Credit: George Hodan/public domain

The current system for checking on a patient’s health and how likely it is to worsen while in hospital is based on weak evidence and using poor scores may harm patients, suggests research published by The BMJ today.

Early warning scores (EWS) are used widely in hospitals to assess and identify clinical deterioration in , based on measuring vital signs such as heart rate, , and blood pressure.

They were introduced as a way of tackling adverse events and unnecessary deaths in hospitals, but so far, there has been little investigation into how the system was developed and validated.

Researchers led by the University of Oxford therefore set out to provide an overview and critical appraisal of early warning scores by reviewing existing studies on the issue.

They analysed the results of 95 studies describing the development or external validation of an early warning score for adult hospital inpatients.

They found that most early warning scores were developed for use in the United Kingdom (29%) and the United States (38%).

Death was the most frequent prediction outcome for development studies (44%) and validation studies (79%), with different time horizons—the most frequent were ‘in-hospital’ and 24 hours.

The most common predictors used in the scores were respiratory rate (88% of studies), (83%), oxygen saturation, temperature, and systolic blood pressure (all 71%). Age (38%) and sex (9%) were less frequently included.

Overall analysis of the results, however, showed that most studies were carried out using poor methods, had inadequate reporting, and all of the studies were at risk of being biased.

Specifically, key details of the analysis populations were often not reported in development studies (41% of these studies) or validation studies (39%).

The researchers found that handling of statistical issues, such as missing data, was inadequate in many of the previous studies, while many also failed to report important details, such as sample size, number of events, population characteristics, and details of statistical methods.

They acknowledge some study limitations, such as the fact that they had assessed fewer development studies than might have been expected because they only included scores published in peer-reviewed journals.

Nevertheless, they conclude that many early warning scores in were found to have methodological and reporting weaknesses and shortcomings.

“Early warning scores might not perform as well as expected and therefore they could have a detrimental effect on patient care,” they say. “Future work should focus on following recommended approaches for developing and evaluating early warning scores, and investigating the impact and safety of using these scores in clinical practice.”

Calculating early warning scores before they reach hospital can help the sickest patients

More information:
Early warning scores for detecting deterioration in adult hospital patients: systematic review and critical appraisal of methodology, BMJ (2020). DOI: 10.1136/bmj.m1501

Doctors should be cautious when using current warning system for patient’s worsening health (2020, May 20)
retrieved 20 May 2020

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


Related posts:

Aldosterone production is a common and unrecognized cause of high blood pressure
US poised to ban travel from Brazil: White House aide
South Korea re-imposes some social restrictions to combat new virus outbreaks
Putzfimmel im Gehirn - Biermann Medizin
Coronavirus infections may lead to delirium and potentially PTSD
SARS-CoV-2 verstehen: Forschungsprojekte ergründen Eigenschaften und Ausbreitung
Researchers develop high-performance cancer vaccine using novel microcapsules
Neuartiges COVID-19-Schnelltestverfahren auf Basis innovativer DNA-Polymerasen entwickelt
Risk of resurgence in COVID-19 if Connecticut reopens too soon
Xtreme Research Award: Prof. Nolan für Arbeiten zum Makulapigment ausgezeichnet
Canada and the U.S. working on extending border closure
Max-Planck-Forscher entwickeln "ultimativen Zellsortierer" - Biermann Medizin
Researchers launche clinical trial to help reduce severity of COVID-19 illness in men
Combinatorial screening approach opens path to better-quality joint cartilage
Study finds childhood cancer does not affect parental separation, divorce, and family planning in De...
'Knowing how' is in your brain
Psoriasis und Psoriasis-Arthritis: Evaluierung veränderbarer Risikofaktoren
Researchers use brain imaging to demonstrate weaker neural suppression for those with autism
Research shows electroceutical fabric eradicates coronaviruses on contact
The prevention of childhood obesity would require stricter advertising regulations
Research team shrinks breast cancer tumors in mice with targeted therapy
Cycling and walking to work lowers risk of cancer, heart disease and death – new research
Neue Emmy Noether-Nachwuchsgruppe erforscht schwere Pilzinfektionen
Warum Lymphdrüsenkrebs das Gehirn befällt
Vorhersage eines Lungenversagens bei Patienten mit COVID-19
France revises down coronavirus death toll
Lipid-metabolism enzyme may aid search in new treatment for chronic inflammatory liver disease
SPD-Experte widerspricht Kinderärzten bei Öffnung von Schule und Kita
Study shows patients with hemorrhagic brain disease have disordered gut microbiomes
Small risk of muscle and bone problems in babies of mothers who took common thrush treatment
Virus spread 'still accelerating' in Brazil, Peru, Chile: WHO regional office
Retinal texture could provide early biomarker of Alzheimer's disease
Schwerer Verlauf von COVID-19:  Welche Lungenpatienten besonderen Schutz brauchen
US begins crackdown on unvetted virus blood tests
Study reveals mental health of medical personnel working with COVID-19 patients
A new potential target for the treatment of alcohol-withdrawal induced depression
India coronavirus death toll passes China's
Defects in developing frog brain can be prevented or repaired with bioelectric drugs
Dr. Ecker erhält Preis für Notfallmedizin
Selbsttonometrie und telemedizinischer Datentransfer: Kick-off-Video zum SALUS-Projekt jetzt online
Schwangerschaft: "Natürlich" bedeutet nicht automatisch gesund
Anxiety needs global health attention
New stroke guidelines aim to improve care amid COVID-19
'Hug glove' gives Canada family bit of normalcy in pandemic
Kein Nutzen von Hydroxychloroquin und Chloroquin
Cavity-causing bacteria assemble an army of protective microbes on human teeth
Turkey confirms 32 deaths, 1,141 new COVID-19 cases
COVID-19 könnte bei Kindern schwere Entzündungserkrankung verursachen
Fear­ful Great Danes provide new in­sights to ge­netic causes of fear
UK adds loss of taste and smell to coronavirus symptoms
New study evaluates facial feminization outcomes, benefits for transgender women
Daily Internet use is linked to social isolation
Ultraviolet light has bright future in fight against COVID-19
Japan newborn gets liver stem cells in world first
MB-Online-Umfrage: Ärzte für behutsame Rückkehr zum Regelbetrieb
Schmerzmedizin im Krankenhaus unter SARS-CoV-2-Bedingungen
France to reopen cafes, end domestic travel limit
First-of-its-kind-study reveals that eating prior to cardiac catheterization is non-inferior to fast
France says no sign of virus rise after lockdown eased
Chirurgie-Ausbildung mit Roboter und Virtueller Realität
US death toll from coronavirus surges past 100,000 people
Up to 60% of students in some schools vaped in past month
Turkey nears end of latest lockdown, death toll up to 4,397
DJO stärkt DACH-Region - Biermann Medizin
Evolution of pandemic coronavirus outlines path from animals to humans
What does recovery from COVID-19 look like?
Knochenkrebs : Die Schwäche des Tumors
Presymptomatic virus patients can contaminate environments: study
Bakterien nutzen NO, um Schleimhaut zu besiedeln
Virus count revised, new clusters emerge as France reopens
Some recommended cardiovascular medications prescribed less frequently to women
Gene inactivation of PTEN drives cancer predisposition
Germany extends distancing rules to end of June
Donating blood to get back to work during COVID-19
COVID-19 disruption will lead to 28 million surgeries cancelled worldwide
Keeping kids slim, fit during lockdown isn't easy: Here are some tips
Minimum legal age for cannabis use should be 19, study suggests
Anti-viral drug remdesivir effective against coronavirus, study finds
Canada bans cruise ship visits until October
Heart surgery stalled as COVID-19 spread
Raumfahrt relevant für die Erforschung von Herz-Kreislauferkrankungen
Europe relaxing virus restrictions but cases flare elsewhere
Managing mental health with yoga
Experts share what you need to know about COVID-19 as states reopen
Study reveals first evidence inherited genetics can drive cancer's spread
Spain to reopen to tourists as South America named virus hotspot
How scientists hope to stop coronavirus in its tracks
New research finds 'Dr. Google' is almost always wrong
Early indicators of vaccine efficacy
COVID-19 trial finder provides simplified search process for COVID-related clinical trials
Illinois mandated 'Stay-at-home' orders, nearby iowa didn't: here's what happened
Voluntary collective isolation is best response to COVID-19 for indigenous populations
Schmerztherapie ohne Opioide nach roboterassistierten Eingriffen
Virus heads upriver in Brazil Amazon, sickens native people
Chemists develop foolproof new test to track the fats we eat
Mögliches Referenzmessverfahren für die Analyse auf SARS-CoV-2
Hospital response risks worsening health inequalities
Analytics and data collecting spur helmet safety in football
Optimal time to treat Huntington's disease identified
Nicht immer lässt sich SARS-CoV-2 über einen Abstrich nachweisen

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Tackling alcohol harms must be an integral part of the nation's recovery from COVID-19

Thu May 21 , 2020
Credit: CC0 Public Domain As the UK and most other countries went into lockdown, the need to save lives from the coronavirus rightly took priority over longer term health issues. But experts writing in The BMJ today warn that “if we don’t prepare for emerging from the pandemic, we will […]