how physicians used it 500 years ago to control the bubonic plague

Contact tracing: how physicians used it 500 years ago to control the bubonic plague
Dance of Death, Michael Wolgemut (1493). Credit: Wikimedia

Contact tracing has been remarkably successful at helping contain the COVID-19 pandemic in South Korea, Australia and Germany, as well as some smaller places. Using 21st-century systems of telecommunications and surveillance, healthcare workers in these places have led the way in identifying those who have been in contact with the infected, and then testing and isolating them.

Minus the modern technology, contact tracing goes back a long way. The American historian William Coleman’s wonderful 1987 book, Yellow Fever in the North, associates “case tracing” with the origins of epidemiology in the mid-. The is spread via mosquitoes and not person to person, but that would only be discovered half a century later.

French physicians fighting yellow fever in the 1840s focused on finding the first case—what we would now call “patient zero”. Later in the 19th century, they began paying greater attention to connections between households, and people inside and outside of them.

The search for syphilis

The ideas behind contact tracing are much older, however. It was anticipated in the early 16th century in relation to the great pox, which would come to be known as syphilis thanks to a poem by the physician Girolamo Fracastoro from 1530. Physicians such as the celebrated anatomist Gabriele Falloppio, chair of medicine at the University of Padua, the citadel of 16th-century medical learning, sought to understand the origins of the disease using a different approach to the norm.

Instead of just relying on what the ancient and early medieval Arabic medical authorities had to say about diseases, Falloppio and other doctors sought to track the spread of this venereal disease by turning to contemporary histories, most prominently Christopher Columbus’s journals.

Through these works, they could track the progression of the disease from the Americas to hospitals in Barcelona. It then spread via soldiers recruited by King Ferdinand II of Aragon, and most significantly with the invasion of Italy and the siege of Naples in the winter of 1495 by King Charles VIII of France.

The siege and the ensuing dispersal of Charles’ mercenary soldiers to their homelands were the “superspreader events” that gave syphilis pandemic force. In the 1530s another physician, Bernardino Tomitano, also a chair of medicine at the University of Padua, followed the disease’s continued spread into eastern Europe, pinning it to Venetian commerce.

The rapid spread of syphilis broadened physicians’ notions about disease transmission and the role played by human carriers. But the earliest known example of doctors searching for specific contacts and disease networks relates not to the great pox but to a disease to which Europe had become grimly accustomed—the bubonic . And the physician involved is not nearly so famous as Falloppio or any chair of medicine at Padua, but a village doctor with a few publications to his name.

While treating patients on the shores of Lake Garda at Desenzano in northern Italy during the outbreak of 1576, Andrea Gratiolo used contact tracing in a manner we can recognise today. It was employed not to trace the spread of plague as such, but to disprove that it derived from a woman who was rumoured to have carried it to Desenzano from where she lived in Trento.

Gratiolo noted that the woman had “taken a small and tightly packed boat with 18 others … sleeping on top one another”. One woman had slept all night with her head in the accused woman’s lap. Gratiolo also investigated the household of the second woman and discovered that “she, her husband and their four small children all slept in the same bed”.

In a plague treatise published later that year, Gratiolo argued that the boat’s passengers and the entire household of the accused should have become infected, yet none had. In further evidence of , he adds: “no other person [the accused] had associated or interacted with had caught the disease”.

Unrepentant rationalists

Gratiolo used the bulk of his treatise to blast universal theories that plague derived from certain configurations of the stars, corruption of air that was “thick, swampy, foggy and stunk”, bad food that corrupted the humours or “rumours that one individual was responsible for the transmission of plague into a large city”.

His notions didn’t spring from an ideological vacuum. During that peninsula-wide plague outbreak of 1574-78, other plague doctors were similarly going against the prevailing orthodoxies of the time.

Gratiolo even questioned the first principle of plague causation from the early Middle Ages that would to some extent endure until the 19th century—that it came from God to punish our sins. It may seem difficult to believe that at the pinnacle of the counter-Reformation, a village doctor argued that the influence of God was “irrelevant, not even a proper question for doctors to be asking”. To curb the spread of diseases, Gratiolo held that doctors should focus on natural causes and leave questions of God to the theologians.

Contact tracing was probably more widespread in 16th-century Europe than historians have been able to show, and not only in Italy. For instance, an undated hospital duty book from Nuremberg in Germany, compiled between 1500 and 1700, lists questions to be asked of every patient wishing treatment at any of the city’s facilities, regardless of the illness. These related to how, when, where and, if possible, from whom the patient had contracted it.

Both this evidence and Gratiolo’s plague investigation are good examples of how the received wisdom about origin stories can be misleading—just as today we may often assume that pandemics originate from a single “patient zero“. By 1576, our country doctor had already questioned that one, too.

China diagnoses 3rd case of bubonic plague

Provided by
The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Contact tracing: how physicians used it 500 years ago to control the bubonic plague (2020, June 3)
retrieved 3 June 2020

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)

Related posts:

Five killed after gunmen storm a South African church, 40 people arrested
Coronavirus Live Updates: As U.S. Cases Rise, States Weigh New Restrictions
Physicians give first comprehensive review of COVID-19's effects outside the lung
LGBT rights at heart of Poland presidential-election fight
Study of Coronavirus in Pregnant Women Finds Striking Racial Differences
Coronavirus deaths take a long-expected turn for the worse
How Covid-19 can damage the brain
Malian anti-govt protests continue despite president's call for dialogue
How to Reopen Schools: What Science and Other Countries Teach Us
Virus cases up sharply in Africa, India as inequality stings
Study highlights multiple health risks among a people living longer with HIV
Jack Charlton, icon of English and Irish football alike, dies at 85
Couldn't socially distance? Blame your working memory
Is what I see, what I imagine? Study finds neural overlap between vision and imagination
Fury in France as protesters slam Macron’s choice of interior minister accused of rape
Abnormally high blood sugar linked with higher risk of death in COVID-19 patients not previously dia...
WHO urges aggressive virus measures as flare-ups spark new closures
US records 63,643 new virus cases in 24 hours
Bosnian Muslims mark 25th anniversary of Srebrenica massacre
Brazil surpasses 70,000 coronavirus deaths
Nano-radiomics unveils treatment effect on tumor microenvironment
Malian president urges calm in overnight address after protesters take state TV off air
Hong Kong opposition pushes ahead with primaries under shadow of security law
US bets on untested company to deliver COVID-19 vaccine
Trump commutes prison sentence of longtime friend Roger Stone
Serbia reports record daily virus death toll
Nearly half of US adults projected to be obese by 2030
Building surge ICU capacity during COVID-19
New research suggests failure to retrieve relevant details from memory may underlie face blindness
Study pinpoints brain cells that trigger sugar cravings and consumption
Cancer health disparities published in new volume
France virus death toll exceeds 30,000
Uzbekistan reimposes virus lockdown after new cases
The people tirelessly restoring Notre-Dame to its former glory
A Confederate flag spotted in the window of police barracks in Paris
Pandemic inspires framework for enhanced care in nursing homes
Mali protesters demand president's resignation over jihadist conflict, economy
They got a big ER bill because hospitals couldn't test for virus
Milde und schwere COVID-19-Erkrankung: Unterschiede der Immunreaktion gegen SARS-CoV-2
Instagram to block all content promoting LGBT ‘conversion therapy’
Serbia, Kosovo resume ‘very difficult’ talks on normalising ties
Coronavirus can still be brought under control: WHO
Kein erhöhtes Demenzrisiko durch Tiefe Hirnstimulation
Balloons bring internet to Kenya's rural Rift Valley
How do COVID-19 antibody tests differ from diagnostic tests?
Virtueller DIVI-Kongress als Novum für 6.000 Teilnehmer
Decades on, 'hidden children' forced into orphanages of colonial France remain traumatised
Macron revamps cabinet, France rules out new lockdown and Louvre reopens
Fat cell hormone boosts potential of stem cell therapy
Neue Studie von UKE-Forschenden: SARS-CoV-2 befällt auch das Herz
UK travellers hope to salvage holidays as government eases quarantine rules
WHO special envoy on Covid-19 'extremely worried' about rise in cases worldwide
Sutter Health’s Request to Delay $575 Million Settlement Is Denied
Florida's curve no longer flat amid new surge of virus cases
DGK für Engagement in der Corona-Krise ausgezeichnet
Turkish court paves way to reconverting Hagia Sophia museum into a mosque
Netherlands takes Russia to European court over 2014 downing of Flight MH17
Coronavirus Live Updates: U.S. Nears 60,000 New Daily Cases
Largest study of prostate cancer genomics in Black Americans IDs targets for therapies
Medienpreis Urologie für fundierte Berichterstattung im Zeitalter von Dr. Google
Teletherapy, Popular in the Pandemic, May Outlast It
Ozone disinfection could safely allow reuse of personal protective equipment
COVID-19-Pandemie: Mehr Fälle des Brocken-Heart-Syndroms
The many lives of Hagia Sophia, Istanbul’s ‘wonder of wonders’
Meet the Heroes Fighting on the Front Lines Against Covid-19
How COVID-19 lockdown has impacted people with arthritis
Intensivmedizin an der Universitätsmedizin Göttingen wird erweitert
PSG to face Italy's Atalanta in Champions League quarter-finals
Study reveals circuit mechanism underlying nociceptive information processing
Kurznotizen am Erbgut - Biermann Medizin
Hong Kong to shut all schools after virus cases spike
Umfrage: Videosprechstunden bekommen in Corona-Krise Schwung
Lebanon’s neo-liberal wheels sped to a dream future, but the past applies the brakes
China vows to hit US with 'reciprocal measures' after Xinjiang sanctions
Why India cases are rising to multiple peaks
Ein Datenschatz für die Ganganalyse
Researchers identify key role of immune cells in brain development
Merkel press office staffer 'worked for years for Egyptian intelligence'
France investigates report of bodies 'left to rot' at Paris research centre
New study supports remdesivir as COVID-19 treatment
Neues Proteomik-Verfahren: Detaillierter Einblick in die gestresste Zelle
US sees latest record surge in virus cases amid wrangling over lockdown measures
Air Pollution Takes a Global Toll on Heart Health
Indoor airborne spread of coronavirus possible
Australia locks down second city as global cases top 12 million
Serbia drops plans for reimposed lockdown after days of violent protests
WHO launches global pandemic response probe
French César awards announce changes in response to Polanski #MeToo brouhaha
Airborne coronavirus transmission raises new questions and worries
Forecasts predict worse EU recession since WWII
reducing your risk of kidney stones
Scientists discover protective Alzheimer's gene and develop rapid drug-testing platform
UK declines participating in EU Covid-19 vaccine scheme over concerns of delays
Technology Bridges the Gap to Better Sight
CT of COVID-19 versus CT of influenza virus pneumonia
Bolivia's President Anez tests positive for Covid-19
Dogs May Be Good for Children’s Psychological Development
New study outlines best practices for delivering care via telehealth
What’s the Best Exercise for You? Twins Can Provide an Answer
A memory game could help us understand brain injury

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *