Mental ill health ‘substantial health concern’ among police, finds international study

Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Mental health issues among police officers are a “substantial health concern,” with around 1 in 4 potentially drinking at hazardous levels and around 1 in 7 meeting the criteria for post traumatic stress disorder and depression, finds a pooled data analysis of the available international evidence, published online in Occupational & Environmental Medicine.

The high prevalence of mental health issues among the emphasises the need for and monitoring programmes as well as extra cash to match the preventive efforts offered to other high risk groups, conclude the researchers.

Published research suggests that first responders run a higher risk of mental health issues than the general public. But it’s not clear how common mental health issues are among police officers, or what the risk factors for these might be.

This is despite the fact that the nature of their work means that the police are uniquely exposed to extreme violence and death while often running the gauntlet of public distrust and disparagement, say the researchers.

To try and plug this knowledge gap, the researchers trawled 16 research databases for relevant studies published between 1980 and October 2019.

They found 67 studies which met their inclusion criteria of involving at least 100 active police professionals and the use of validated measures to assess specific aspects of mental ill health. The overall study quality was high (46%) or moderate (54%).

The studies included a total of 272,463 police officers from 24 countries and covered post (PTSD), depression, substance misuse, anxiety disorder, and suicidal thoughts (ideation).

Most of the studies came from North America (46%), Europe (28%), and Australia (10%) and primarily featured male officers with an average age of 39, carrying out general duties.

Pooled analysis of the data indicated that the estimated prevalence of mental health issues among police officers was substantial, and more than double the rate reported in several previously published studies.

Around one in four (just under 26%) screened positive for hazardous drinking, while one in seven met the criteria for PTSD (14%) or depression (14.5%).

Around one in 10 met the criteria for anxiety disorder (9.5%) and (8.5%), while one in 20 (5%) would be considered to be drinking at harmful levels or to be alcohol dependent.

Low levels of peer support, higher levels of job stress, and poor (avoidant) coping strategies were all strong for , the data analysis suggested. Female sex was also a consistent risk factor for poorer mental health.

The researchers acknowledge that the study methods and designs varied widely, and that many of the included studies were observational and relied on subjective symptom reporting.

Nevertheless, the findings prompt them to deduce: “Police officers show a substantial burden of mental health problems, emphasising the need for effective interventions and monitoring programmes.”

Otherwise, “psychological difficulties will remain a substantial health concern among police,” they conclude.

A major problem, however, is that in the absence of good evidence no one can agree on what these interventions should be, they point out.

“Further research into interventions that address stress and peer support in the police is needed, taking into account risk differences between genders and cultures,” they say, adding: “The results support increased funding initiatives for police wellbeing to match preventative efforts currently offered in other high-risk populations.”

How do encounters with police affect the mental health of black Americans?

More information:
Global prevalence and risk factors for mental health problems in police personnel: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Occupational & Environmental Medicine, DOI: 10.1136/oemed-2020-106498

Mental ill health ‘substantial health concern’ among police, finds international study (2020, May 21)
retrieved 21 May 2020

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


Related posts:

Corona-Antikörpertests: Sichere Ergebnisse im Fokus
Global spread of the multi-resistant pathogen Stenotrophomonas maltophilia
Germany kicks off as Europe eases curbs but virus marches on
Studie zum Infektionsgeschehen an Schulen
Preventing 'cytokine storm' may ease severe COVID-19 symptoms
DKOU 2020 abgesagt - Biermann Medizin
Apremilast bei pädiatrischer Psoriasis
Britain divided over reopening schools as virus rules ease
Daily Internet use is linked to social isolation
Why pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma is so lethal
WHO-Studie: Jeder fünfte Jugendliche in Deutschland ist zu dick
New research finds 'Dr. Google' is almost always wrong
Public information key to combating rising 'superbug' threat
Herz und Lunge: Studienprojekt zu COVID-19-Folgen bei Sportlern
The malaria parasite P. vivax can remain in the spleen upon expression of certain proteins
Minimum legal age for cannabis use should be 19, study suggests
Russia reports record high daily virus death toll
New infections show virus accelerating across Latin America
'Hug glove' gives Canada family bit of normalcy in pandemic
Risk of resurgence in COVID-19 if Connecticut reopens too soon
Voluntary collective isolation is best response to COVID-19 for indigenous populations
IQWiG bleibt dabei: Nutzen des PSA-Screenings wiegt den Schaden nicht auf
Ärzte sind keine „Digitalisierungsassistenten“ - Biermann Medizin
Is your job killing you? Stress, lack of autonomy, ability can lead to depression, death
Vienna Philharmonic says no increased virus risk for orchestras
Loosened restrictions, holiday weekend to test California
Besonders fitte Antikörper sollen gegen SARS-CoV-2 helfen
Study quantifies China's chronic health burden for the first time
Epilepsy-related deaths common in young adults and are not reducing, new research shows
Leibniz-WissenschaftsCampus EvoLUNG erhält erneut Förderung
AbbVie schließt Übernahme von Allergan ab
Leitlinie „Neurogene Dysphagie“ komplett überarbeitet
Schulterschluss der Herzmedizin – Wir dulden keinen Rassismus
Antivirales Medikament gegen COVID-19 erstmalig am Dresdner Uniklinikum erfolgreich eingesetzt
Using telehealth to transition diabetes inpatients to virtual care during COVID-19
Incidence of AMI hospitalization down during COVID-19
Continuously active surface disinfectants may provide additional barrier against the spread of virus...
High-quality end-of-life care will enable older people with frailty to live well and die well
Heart attack prevention lags for people with stroke, peripheral artery disease
COVID-19 könnte bei Kindern schwere Entzündungserkrankung verursachen
Slovenia opens borders after declaring epidemic over
Analytics and data collecting spur helmet safety in football
Häufiger Harndrang als Symptom von COVID-19?
Insomnia may forecast depression, thinking problems in older people
Retinal texture could provide early biomarker of Alzheimer's disease
Healthcare rationing could see 'unlawful deaths' from COVID-19, researchers claim
Analysis of COVID-19 genomes reveals large numbers of introductions to the UK in March
Heart attacks, heart failure, stroke: COVID-19's dangerous cardiovascular complications
Verlässlicher Schutz für Patienten und Mitarbeiter: Aufnahmescreening auf SARS-CoV-2
Europe reopens widely; China gives $2 billion to virus fight
The cholera outbreak in a Victorian asylum that anticipated the coronavirus crisis in care homes
US health officials quietly release more reopening guidance
MB-Online-Umfrage: Ärzte für behutsame Rückkehr zum Regelbetrieb
Krebs im Kindesalter: Den richtigen Zeitpunkt für ein Gespräch zum Lebensende finden
Schmerzmedizin im Krankenhaus unter SARS-CoV-2-Bedingungen
Germans opt for staycations as virus fears linger
France virus toll nears 28,500 as daily deaths slow
COVID-19: Studie zur Therapie der schweren Entzündungsreaktion
Blood flow recovers faster than brain in micro strokes
EU calls for independent probe of WHO's pandemic response
New virus deaths in Spain fall to two-month low under 100
New research shows that increasing number of lost pregnancies is linked to higher risk of developing...
Kontaktekzem: Biologischer Wirkstoff mögliche Therapieoption
Turkey records 29 deaths, 987 new COVID-19 cases
DGVS mahnt Rückkehr zur regulären Früherkennung an
Bakterien nutzen NO, um Schleimhaut zu besiedeln
Heart failure patients with limited health literacy may have higher risk of death
New study could pave way to cure of global parasite
New studies reveal extent and risks of laughing gas and stimulant abuse among young people
Spain revises virus death toll down by nearly 2,000
Anti-viral drug remdesivir effective against coronavirus, study finds
Coronavirus may never go away: WHO
Warum Lymphdrüsenkrebs das Gehirn befällt
No improvements seen in meeting AAP vitamin D intake guidelines
Spain govt seeks 2-week extension of lockdown
High-tech devices help NFL teams keep players safe, in shape
CD4+-Zellen auf der Überholspur
Americans and Europeans soak up the sun amid new rules
STAAB-Studie: Mehr als die Hälfte der Probanden haben Vorstufe einer Herzinsuffizienz
Schmerztherapie ohne Opioide nach roboterassistierten Eingriffen
Doctors should be cautious when using current warning system for patient's worsening health
Hemmung zelleigenen Enzyms: Strategie für Entwicklung antiviraler Breitbandwirkstoffe
COVID-19 und der neue Alltag mit Maske: Welche sind wofür geeignet?
Zu wenig Schlaf hängt auch bei Erwachsenen mit häufigeren Asthmaanfällen zusammen
Mortality rates hint at even higher coronavirus death toll
COVID-19 patients may have lower stroke rates than previously suggested
UK govt boosts vaccine funding as daily virus deaths fall
Combinatorial screening approach opens path to better-quality joint cartilage
Pandemic halts vaccination for nearly 80 million children
Russia's virus spread stabilising: top health official
Angst vor COVID-19 verzögert Diagnose und Therapie bei Krebspatienten
Tracking, data privacy and getting the numbers right
Sozioökonomische Faktoren beeinflussen Lebensqualität nach einer Herzoperation
Blood clotting abnormalities reveal COVID-19 patients at risk for thrombotic events
Neue Angiographie-Einheit erweitert Behandlungsmöglichkeiten deutlich
Im März die meisten Laufverletzungen
Cavity-causing bacteria assemble an army of protective microbes on human teeth
Krankheitserreger nutzen Stickstoffmonoxid bei der Schleimhaut-Besiedlung
Lipid-metabolism enzyme may aid search in new treatment for chronic inflammatory liver disease
Sociodemographic factors associated with a positive test for COVID-19 in primary care

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Have a reusable face mask? Here's how to wash it the right way

Fri May 22 , 2020
Credit: CC0 Public Domain Since the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has recommended cloth face coverings for the general public, many have relied on those while reserving medical masks, such as N95 respirators, for medical workers. While there are ways to properly wear and remove face masks in general […]