Online exercise advice rarely aligns with national physical activity guidelines

physical activity
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Whether for convenience, cost or comfort, many people look to online resources for fitness and exercise information—especially when faced with fitness center and gym closures during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Unfortunately, most internet-based recommendations for physical activity don’t match up with the guidelines supported by national health organizations, a recent study from Oregon State University found.

“Online advice is incomprehensible for many and incomplete for everybody,” said researcher Brad Cardinal, a kinesiology professor in OSU’s College of Public Health and Human Sciences. “There wasn’t anything we came across that was a complete message, and for many people, they would be left out of it altogether.”

The dearth of reliable physical activity information online exacerbates existing health inequities, Cardinal said, because the information often is tailored for people who are already active and comfortable in the exercise world. For those who are trying to initiate physical activity for the first time, such incomplete information could lead to accidents or injuries, as well as feelings of stigmatization and exclusion.

The study, published earlier this month in the Translational Journal of the American College of Sports Medicine, analyzed fitness recommendations in 72 web articles from four types of organizations: government, commercial sites, professional associations and voluntary health agencies. Researchers compared the information with the national Physical Activity Guidelines set by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

The national guidelines advise adults to “move more and sit less” throughout the day. For “substantial health benefits,” they say adults should complete 150 to 300 minutes (2.5 to 5 hours) of moderate aerobic activity, or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic activity, each week, spread across several days. Additional health benefits can be gained by exercising more than 300 minutes. The guidelines also recommend adults do some moderate- or greater-intensity strength-training activity that involves all muscle groups at least two days a week.

“Moderate” aerobic activity means something like a brisk walk, Cardinal said—about a pace of 3 or 4 miles per hour, when you can still comfortably hold a conversation.

The guidelines are mostly the same for adults ages 65 and older and for adults with disabilities or , but include the caveat that if people in these groups are unable to complete the full recommendations, they should be as “physically active as their abilities and conditions allow.”

In their analysis, the researchers found that professional associations such as nationally accredited groups of health care providers were the best at sharing accurate information, including total recommended minutes, spreading exercise throughout the week, and explaining how the time recommendation shifts based on the intensity of the activity.

Across all four types of sites the researchers studied, recommendations were more likely to be correct on aerobic exercise; very few included correct or complete information on muscle-strengthening activity.

While the national guidelines focus on “hearts and lungs,” most online advice focuses on “abs and buns,” Cardinal said—meaning the intent is more about improving appearance than about health.

His previous research has shown that online exercise messages also include a lot of hidden advertising, often for costly workout gear or “health food” products, which can add another perceived barrier to low-income folks trying to start exercising.

“For people who are inactive, and even people whose jobs include active labor but are hoping to develop an exercise routine, the online information was generally unhelpful,” Cardinal said. “The majority of articles focused on those who were already involved in an exercise program.” This finding was affirmed in another study that examined the same web articles’ production quality.

“It’s good to reinforce the message for people who are active; it’s good to give them encouragement. But if someone is new to this or has been away from for a while, the materials aren’t really comprehensive for people,” he said. “They’re going to feel overwhelmed by them, and they’re going to get an incomplete and inaccurate picture of what to do, and they could end up doing things wrong and potentially getting themselves hurt. The might be doing more harm than good.”

Lead author on the study was Jafrā D. Thomas, a 2019 Ph.D. graduate in kinesiology at OSU who is now an assistant professor at the California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo.

Variety is key for the fittest Americans

More information:
Jafrā D. Thomas et al, How Credible Is Online Physical Activity Advice? The Accuracy of Free Adult Educational Materials, Translational Journal of the ACSM (2020). DOI: 10.1249/TJX.0000000000000122

Online exercise advice rarely aligns with national physical activity guidelines (2020, May 14)
retrieved 14 May 2020

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


Related posts:

Newborn may have contracted coronavirus in the womb
Treating skin irritations from wearing face masks
Italy to reopen borders on June 3 to restart tourism
Vaccine hopes and economic woes as virus spreads
Early indicators of vaccine efficacy
Lagerungsschwindel – Einfache Frage zur Diagnose?
India yogi who claimed to live without food or water dies aged 90
Blood clotting abnormalities reveal COVID-19 patients at risk for thrombotic events
Studie zum Infektionsgeschehen an Schulen
Nearly half of Moroccans 'anxious' under lockdown: study
Experts share what you need to know about COVID-19 as states reopen
Krebs im Kindesalter: Den richtigen Zeitpunkt für ein Gespräch zum Lebensende finden
Blood flow recovers faster than brain in micro strokes
Liverpool-Atletico match linked to '41 additional' virus deaths: report
Loosened restrictions, holiday weekend to test California
CD4+-Zellen auf der Überholspur
Compression stockings might not be needed to prevent blood clots after surgery
Psychedelic experiences disrupt routine thinking—and so has the coronavirus pandemic
France reports drop in coronavirus deaths, toll tops 27,000
Krankheitserreger nutzen Stickstoffmonoxid bei der Schleimhaut-Besiedlung
Angst vor COVID-19 verzögert Diagnose und Therapie bei Krebspatienten
Managing mental health with yoga
New study could pave way to cure of global parasite
Kein Nutzen von Hydroxychloroquin und Chloroquin
why we're using llamas to help fight the pandemic
Genome study links DNA changes to the risks of specific breast cancer subtypes
Ten-year results display strong safety and efficacy profile for TPV device
Virologe Streeck wehrt sich gegen Vorwürfe: „Doof gelaufen“
3-D-RoboticScope: Operieren mit einem Kopfnicken
No new virus deaths in Ireland for first time 10 weeks
Europe relaxing virus restrictions but cases flare elsewhere
Study reveals mental health of medical personnel working with COVID-19 patients
Russia reports record coronavirus deaths, recoveries
Cavity-causing bacteria assemble an army of protective microbes on human teeth
I-call – Wenn Mikroimplantate miteinander kommunizieren
US maternal health spending varies by state, driven by cost of childbirth
New research shows that increasing number of lost pregnancies is linked to higher risk of developing...
Spain to reopen to tourists as South America named virus hotspot
Deutsche Krebshilfe und die Arbeitsgemeinschaft Dermatologische Prävention raten zu neuer Normalität...
Could interferon drugs help fight COVID-19?
New York's daily virus death toll falls below 100: governor
Hospital response risks worsening health inequalities
Scientists fight online virus misinformation war
Ärzte-Statistik: 402.000 Ärzte in Deutschland
Turkey records 29 deaths, 987 new COVID-19 cases
Epilepsy-related deaths common in young adults and are not reducing, new research shows
Mit Hochdurchsatz gegen Krebs und COVID-19
Japan set to lift coronavirus emergency as cases slow
Dr. Ecker erhält Preis für Notfallmedizin
Preventing 'cytokine storm' may ease severe COVID-19 symptoms
COVID-19 patients may have lower stroke rates than previously suggested
Glucose levels linked to maternal mortality even in non-diabetic women
US begins crackdown on unvetted virus blood tests
Endgültiges Aus für Mentholzigarette in der EU
COVID-19 death counts 'substantial underestimation' of actual deaths for some Italian regions
Antarctica's splendid isolation keeps coronavirus at bay
Antihormonelle Krebstherapien auf dem Weg zur Gleichberechtigung
Study finds that aging neurons accumulate DNA damage
SARS-CoV-2 verstehen: Forschungsprojekte ergründen Eigenschaften und Ausbreitung
Coronavirus deaths top 325,000 worldwide
Binge drinkers beware, drunkorexia is calling
Germany extends distancing rules to end of June
Preclinical study offers hope for Hirschsprung's disease
Möglicher Übertragungsweg? Erstmals SARS-CoV-2 in Muttermilch nachgewiesen
Nicht immer lässt sich SARS-CoV-2 über einen Abstrich nachweisen
Multi-drug regimen for heart failure could meaningfully extend patients' lives
AI successfully used to identify different types of brain injuries
Hemmung zelleigenen Enzyms: Strategie für Entwicklung antiviraler Breitbandwirkstoffe
New virus deaths in Spain fall to two-month low under 100
Incidence of AMI hospitalization down during COVID-19
Gentherapie: Neues Verfahren zur kontinuierlichen Produktion viraler Vektoren
Global study finds women less likely to have heart disease—and die of it—than men
Corona-Antikörpertests: Sichere Ergebnisse im Fokus
Countering the negative effects of a common antidepressant
Studie enthüllt viele Möglichkeiten, wie Karzinogene die Entwicklung von Brustkrebs auslösen
High-tech devices help NFL teams keep players safe, in shape
Germans opt for staycations as virus fears linger
Turkey registers 41 new deaths, lowest since end of March
COVID-19 disruption will lead to 28 million surgeries cancelled worldwide
Ärzte sind keine „Digitalisierungsassistenten“ - Biermann Medizin
Turkey confirms 32 deaths, 1,141 new COVID-19 cases
Heart attack prevention lags for people with stroke, peripheral artery disease
Minimum legal age for cannabis use should be 19, study suggests
Hilfe für Beatmungspatienten: Mit Salbe soll Sauerstoffaufnahme über die Haut erhöht werden
Psoriasis und Psoriasis-Arthritis: Evaluierung veränderbarer Risikofaktoren
US health officials quietly release more reopening guidance
Leibniz-WissenschaftsCampus EvoLUNG erhält erneut Förderung
Defects in developing frog brain can be prevented or repaired with bioelectric drugs
Norditalien: COVID-19-Sterbezahlen bilden Auswirkungen der Pandemie nur unvollständig ab
Madagascar's 'green gold' against COVID-19 seeks nod beyond Africa
Aldosterone production is a common and unrecognized cause of high blood pressure
Kontaktekzem: Biologischer Wirkstoff mögliche Therapieoption
Analysemethoden nehmen Einfluss auf das Ergebnis
Most parents concerned about privacy, body image impact of tweens using health apps
Mayor says Mexico City will begin gradual reopening June 1
Dairy-rich diet linked to lower risks of diabetes and high blood pressure
Thailand malls reopen, with temperatures taken, masks worn
Coronavirus befällt auch Nieren und andere Organe
Knochenkrebs : Die Schwäche des Tumors
Ist das Nervensystem bei SARS-CoV-2-Infektionen beteiligt?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Rëndohet situata në Turqi rritet numri i të vdekurve

Thu May 14 , 2020
19 persona janë shëruar nga coronavirus në Kosovë. Kështu ka njoftuar Instituti Kombëtar i Shëndetit Publik me anë të një njoftimi ku ka treguar edhe se sot janë konfirmuar 18 raste të reja me coronavirus. Numri i personave të shëruar sipas IKSHP-së, deri më sot është gjithsej 690 raste. IKSHP […]