Some doctors think face shields protect against the coronavirus as well as masks

loading...

mask
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Now that we’ve gotten used to the idea of wearing masks or bandannas when we go out in public, some doctors are proposing an alternative.

They think that face shields—curved sheets of clear plastic that cover the entire face—are as good as masks on some measures of infection control while allowing for better breathing and communication.

Three University of Iowa infectious disease doctors and hospital epidemiologists recently suggested in a Journal of the American Medical Association article, that face shields may be a better option than masks for the general public in community settings, and some of their peers agree with them.

For example, Ravina Kullar, a spokesperson for the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and an infectious disease consultant to Los Angeles nursing homes, recently bought a for forays into her Santa Monica neighborhood. “I would say a face shield alone is better than a ,” she said, referring to people who are not in health care settings. “You don’t need both.”

Daniel McQuillan, an infectious disease doctor at Lahey Hospital and Medical Center and IDSA vice president, also recently bought a shield after a hockey supply company started making them. He finds it more comfortable to wear and says he doesn’t touch his face as much as when he’s wearing a mask. Plus the shield covers his eyes, an entry point for the virus that is not protected by masks. “I think this is something that can be pushed out to lots of people and have a reasonable public health impact in addition to people wearing masks,” he said.

The division of infectious diseases and PolicyLab at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia this month recommended that certain teachers opt for shields when schools reopen. It’s particularly important, the group said, for students who are deaf or hearing impaired or have autism spectrum disorder to be able to see the teacher’s entire face.

There are holdouts. Gregory Poland, a prominent infectious diseases and vaccine specialist at the Mayo Clinic, is one of them. “All of the air that you breathe with a shield is unfiltered,” he said. The author of a study the Iowa doctors use to bolster their argument also worries that small virus-laden droplets could bypass a shield through the sides or bottom. “I wear a mask,” said the author, William Lindsley, a research biomedical engineer at NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Health and Safety) in Morgantown, W. Va.

The debate hinges on how the coronavirus spreads. Shield supporters say it travels primarily through large respiratory droplets that infect the body through mucus membranes in the nose, mouth and eyes. These generally fall quickly to the ground after, say, a cough and could be stopped almost completely by a shield. Like some other infectious disease doctors, Eli Perencevich, the lead author of the JAMA paper, noted that someone with a true airborne disease like measles can infect many more people than someone with COVID-19. Measles and chicken pox typically infect 90% of household members while the infects 10 to 15 percent.

But Poland and Lindsley say there’s reason to think the virus can also spread through smaller droplets or aerosols that could travel farther before falling or even float. In that case, the gaps behind and under shields are weak points. Of course, most cloth and medical masks—the blue kind you see people wearing in medical settings—also have gaps, but they fit closer to the face. They are likely better at what’s called “source control,” or stopping viral spread when the mask wearer coughs.

Everyone agrees that nothing available to the is perfect, which is why we’re also told to stay six feet away from each other and wash our hands frequently. “There is no safe,” Poland said. “There’s only mitigation.”

The best protection is N95 masks, which fit snugly and can filter out most viruses. These are still in short supply and experts say they should be reserved for medical personnel. Within hospitals, medical workers wear N95s covered by shields during procedures that aerosolize virus, such as inserting or removing breathing tubes.

Public mask wearing has become highly politicized, with some arguing that masks are dehumanizing or impair breathing. Even Lindsley says shields are probably better than nothing for people who can’t or won’t wear a face mask, but adds that he personally would not wear a shield alone.

Robert Bettiker, an infectious disease doctor at Temple University Hospital, said he’s not sure whether he would recommend a shield alone. “I would give it a qualified maybe,” he said. “We think it’s much better than nothing. It’s probably as good as a mask, but we just don’t have the data to support that.”

Stopping large droplets, he said, would probably greatly reduce spread on a societal scale. He has been wearing a mask on shopping trips. He’ll likely add a shield now.

Neither the Philadelphia nor Pennsylvania health departments address shields in their guidance to the public. They just recommend that people cover their in public. James Garrow, a spokesman for the Philadelphia department, said officials there believe people are more likely to accept masks than shields. “There are situations—like for servers in restaurants—where face shields used in combination with masks can be beneficial and protective.,” he said. The New Jersey health department encourages face coverings, but not shields alone.

Perencevich said shields have multiple practical advantages over masks, which are often worn incorrectly. They cover the eyes and are easily cleaned with soap and water. People are less likely to touch their faces—another way of spreading the virus—while wearing them. They’re cooler and don’t make glasses fog. It’s easier to breathe while wearing them. People can see you smile and read your lips. Unlike masks, they are impermeable, at least in the plastic parts. (A good shield should cover your whole face, extending to the ears on the side and below the chin on the bottom. There should be no gap at the forehead.)

Lindsley’s study in 2014 used flu virus and breathing and coughing simulators to measure the effectiveness of and shields. It found that face shields blocked 96% of flu virus in large droplets from reaching a simulator wearing a shield a foot and a half away and 68% of small droplets. The study did not look at whether it would protect others for the cougher to wear a shield. Lindsley is studying that now.

“A face shield is not going to be nearly as good as a mask at source control,” he said. The mask is more likely to absorb droplets, while a shield can deflect them and send them sideways or down. He said the shields are best at protecting you from someone who is sneezing or coughing right at you.

Perencevich said that, when someone wearing a shield coughs, the droplets are likely to either stop at the or bounce back onto the mask wearer. “It’s not a trampoline for a droplet,” he said.

Poland thinks shields “have their place” but he’s not convinced. “Before we migrate to what sounds good,” he said, “show me the data.”


Follow the latest news on the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak


©2020 The Philadelphia Inquirer
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Citation:
Some doctors think face shields protect against the coronavirus as well as masks (2020, June 30)
retrieved 30 June 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-06-doctors-shields-coronavirus-masks.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.



loading...
(Visited 4 times, 1 visits today)

Related posts:

Nurses and midwives take the lead in providing HIV services in Eastern and Southern Africa
Brazil's President Bolsonaro taking - and pushing
Drug treatment could improve effectiveness of immunotherapy for cancer patients
Menthol cigarette ban in the US may lower number of smokers
Higher fruit, vegetable and whole grain intake linked to lower risk of diabetes
Experimental drug shows early promise against inherited form of ALS, trial indicates
Harvard, MIT sue Trump administration over revoking foreign student visas
Large-scale fall prevention study finds smaller than expected benefit
NfL outperforms other blood tests to predict and diagnose traumatic brain injury
Ivorian Prime Minister Amadou Gon Coulibaly dies at 61
Angeborene Herzfehler: Veränderungen der Hirnstruktur mit MRT schon im Mutterleib erkennen
A helping hand for cancer immunotherapy
Second wave of Covid-19 sweeps Iran, 'affecting the elderly, young and children' (1/2)
UK announces £30bn Covid-19 stimulus package aimed at young people
Schnelltests auf Streptokokken und Antibiotika-Verordnungen
Recognize symptoms of salmonella infection
New Data Sheds Light on Who Is Moving Because of the Pandemic
Covid-19: The United States' shifting epicentres
BdP: "Krankenkassen lassen die Lungenärzte im Regen stehen"
Libyan deminers clear Tripoli of hidden threats
Researchers work to better measure delirium severity in older patients
Judge Puts Cloud Over Settlement of Roundup Cancer Claims
Lebanese turn to Facebook to swap goods for food
STAT5-Transkriptionsfaktoren wirken sich im braunen Fett positiv gegen die Fettleibigkeit aus
Supreme Court rules employers can refuse to provide birth control on religious grounds
Iran says virus deaths cross 12,000
W.H.O. to Review Evidence of Airborne Transmission of Coronavirus
Covid-19 has exposed the limits of 'fact-denying populism', Merkel tells European Parliament
DFG fördert Task Force zu COVID-19
France rules out 'total lockdown' in case of Covid-19 surge
Why going camping could be the answer to your lockdown holiday woes
8 Questions From a Disease Detective on the Pandemic’s Origins
Diabetische Nephropathie: Studien zur Proteomanalyse zeigen keinen Nutzen
Simulations with actors prepare nurses for the demands of their profession
Trump Administration Signals Formal Withdrawal From W.H.O.
WHO: Ausmaß von Luftübertragung von Coronaviren noch unklar
French PM defends promotion of minister accused of rape after feminist backlash
Why some people won't wear face masks even if told to
Tumor-Therapie im Spiegel: Checkpoint-Blockade durch D-Peptid für Immuntherapie gegen Krebs
Team creates a collaborative platform to streamline brain metastasis research
Neue internationale Empfehlungen für nicht tuberkulöse Mykobakterien veröffentlicht
Deconstructing glioblastoma complexity reveals its pattern of development
Rodin Museum in Paris sells bronzes to make up for crippling shutdown
DGEM-Vorstand: Bosy-Westphal aus Kiel ist neue Vorsitzende
WHO says Sri Lanka and Maldives eliminate measles, rubella
Neutralisierende Antikörper im Kampf gegen COVID-19
Trump sees Kanye West White House bid as ‘trial run’ for 2024
France rules out 'total lockdown' in case of new COVID-19 spike
EU: Corona verändert Drogenkonsum - Biermann Medizin
Men and younger adults less active in lockdown
Erster COVID-19-Patient in Deutschland erfolgreich mit neuer Zwerchfelltherapie behandelt
Nurse misreads symptoms of her own heart attack
Neues Studienzentrum: Bewegungsstörungen im Fokus
New French PM Castex pledges €7.5 billion for hospital staff in wake of pandemic
Proposed study would test at-home screening for HPV and cervical cancer
Thousands protest in Belgrade as Serbia reimposes Covid-19 curfew
A dangerous antibiotic-resistant bacteria may now lurk in U.S. water, soil
China transforms Hong Kong hotel into new security agency headquarters
COVID-19 outbreaks at meat processing plants are hitting minorities hard
FBI chief says China is blackmailing dissenters in US to force them back home
Study explores if insurance is keeping pace with trends in targeted cancer therapy
Two studies look at COVID-19 in patients who have received kidney transplants or are undergoing dial...
Trump's niece brands him a liar and a cheat in new book, White House cries foul
Twins joined at head separated at Vatican pediatric hospital
Increase in delirium, rare brain inflammation and stroke linked to COVID-19
Trump moves to formally withdraw US from World Health Organisation
Chile tops 300,000 virus cases, plans to lift lockdown
Welcome, Robin the AI robot
Revamped French government takes office, tasked with restoring coronavirus-hit economy
Herzinfarktpatienten während der Coronavirus-Pandemie: Gefährliche Angst vor dem Virus
Policies fall short on expanding access to birth control
Was bleibt vom Applaus für die Krankenhäuser?
Unique tool paves the way for more individualized cancer treatments
„Leere Klinikambulanzen“? KBV-Vorstand wundert sich über Selbstwahrnehmung der DKG
French feminists criticise choice of justice, interior ministers over sexism and rape claims
Can the Trauma of War Lead to Growth, Despite the Scars?
Better treatment for people with inflammatory bowel disease
New app launched to battle swarms
Hoher Cholesterinspiegel? Besser Kohlenhydrate sparen als ungesättigte Fettsäuren
Deutsche Bank fined $150 million for failing to flag Jeffrey Epstein accounts
Novavax Gets $1.6 Billion for Coronavirus Vaccine From Operation Warp Speed
Researchers create air filter that can kill the coronavirus
Covid-19 pandemic accelerating and global peak still to come, WHO says
Nicht invasive Diagnostik bei Verdacht auf KHK: IQWiG sieht aussagekräftige Evidenz
Brazil's President Bolsonaro tests positive for coronavirus
‘It Will Consume Your Life’: 4 Families Take On Rare Diseases
Europe coronavirus deaths top 200,000
Libya’s civil war leaves Sahara community without gas, electricity or water
Hilfe bei Diabetes - Biermann Medizin
Live Coronavirus Updates: Testing Demand in U.S. Soars
Types of flu people encounter in childhood may affect susceptibility to different flu strains later ...
Aerobes Training am Morgen bessert Schlaf nach Herz-Bypass
Patient Is Reported Free of H.I.V., but Scientists Urge Caution
One million epilepsy patients in China missing out on beneficial surgery
Wegweiser für die Wundheilung: Erstmals Kleeblattpeptid synthetisiert
A Shot to Protect Against H.I.V.
Improved cancer immunotherapies require radical CAR overhaul
Accident or sabotage? What we know of incident at Iran's Natanz nuclear site
Rheuma: Herz und Gefäße leiden oft mit
Mumbai opens new hospitals as India virus deaths top 20,000

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

In Early February, the Coronavirus Was Moving Through New York

Tue Jun 30 , 2020
A new study offers the first physical evidence that the coronavirus was circulating at low levels in New York City as early as the first week of February. The city confirmed its first infection on March 1. Mathematical models have predicted that the virus was making its way through the […]