Three moral virtues necessary for an ethical pandemic response and reopening


health
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

The health and economic impacts of the coronavirus pandemic are not equally felt. From the United States to Brazil and the United Kingdom, low-wage workers are suffering more than others and communities of color are most vulnerable to the virus.

Despite the disparities, countries are reopening without a plan to redress these unequal harms and protect the broader community going forward. Our ethics research examines the potential for using virtues as a guide for a more moral coronavirus response.

Virtues are applied morals—actions that promote individual and collective well-being. Examples include generosity, compassion, honesty, solidarity, fortitude, justice and patience. While often embedded in religion, virtues are ultimately a secular concept. Because of their broad, longstanding relevance to human societies, these values tend to be held across cultures.

We propose three core virtues to guide policymakers in easing out of coronavirus crisis mode in ways that achieve a better new normal: compassion, solidarity and justice.

1. Compassion

Compassion is a core virtue of all the world’s major religions and a bedrock moral principle in professions like health care and social work. The distinguishing characteristic of compassion is “shared suffering:” Compassionate people and policies recognize suffering and take actions to alleviate it.

As the French philosopher André Comte-Sponville said, compassion “means that one refuses to regard any suffering as a matter of indifference or any living being as a thing.”

Individual acts of compassion abound in the coronavirus crisis, like frontline professionals and neighbors who deliver food, among other examples.

Some pandemic-era policies also reflect compassion, such as regulations preventing evictions and expanding unemployment benefits and giving food aid to poor familes.

A compassion-guided reopening aimed at preventing or reducing human suffering would require governments to continually monitor and alleviate the pain of their people. That includes addressing new forms of suffering that arise as circumstances change.

2. Solidarity

In a global pandemic, the actions people do or don’t take affect the health of others worldwide. Such shared emergencies require solidarity, which recognizes both the inherent dignity of each individual person and the interdependence of all people. As United Nations officials have emphasized, “we are all in this together.”

Public measures like stay-at-home orders, social distancing and wearing masks reflect solidarity. While compliance in the United States has not been universal, data indicate broad approval for these measures. A new study found that 80% of Americans nationwide support staying home and social distancing and 74% support using face coverings in public.

To achieve these acts of solidarity, the leaders most praised in their countries and abroad—from U.S. National Institutes of Health director Dr. Anthony Fauci to New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern—have relied primarily on moral persuasion, not threats of punishment.

By delivering clear information, giving simple and repeated behavioral guidance, and setting a good example, they’ve helped convince millions to take personal responsibility for protecting their community.

3. Justice

Justice focuses on the fair distribution of resources and the social structures that enable what the Dutch philosopher Patrick Loobuyck has called a “condition of equality.”

Justice-oriented policies are necessary for a moral reopening because of the pandemic’s disproportionate health and economic impacts. The evidence clearly shows that communities of color, low-income populations, people in nursing homes and those on the margins of society, such as homeless people and undocumented immigrants, are hardest hit.

Justice-oriented policies would aim for equitable balancing of necessary pandemic resources. That means directing testing and health equipment toward vulnerable communities—as identified by COVID-19 tracking data and risk factors like housing density and poverty—and ensuring free, widespread vaccine distribution when it becomes available.

In the U.S., economic justice will also require aggressively investing in minority-run businesses and poorer areas to guard against further harm to owners, employees and neighborhoods.

Similarly, all American school children have lost critical classroom hours, but lower-income children have been disproportionately damaged by remote learning in part due to the digital divide and loss of free lunch programs. Justice would demand channeling additional resources to the students and schools that need them most.

A moral reopening

Using virtues to guide social policies is an old idea. It dates back at least to the Greek thinker Aristotle.

New Zealand is a good example of virtuous pandemic policymaking, even considering its advantages in having wealth, low density and no land borders. Its coronavirus response included not only aggressive public health measures but also a well articulated message of being united in the COVID-19 fight and recurring government payments so workers did not have to risk their health for their job.

Note that it isn’t enough to apply just one virtue in a crisis of this magnitude. Policies built on , solidarity and justice should be deployed in combination.

A compassionate post-pandemic response that does not address underlying inequalities, for example, ignores certain communities’ specific needs. Meanwhile, tackling specific injustices without engaging everyone in efforts like mask-wearing endangers the public health.

Bolstered by , virtue ethics can help nations reopen not just economically but morally, too.


Poll: British public value protecting lives over economic prosperity during COVID-19 pandemic


Provided by
The Conversation


This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Citation:
Three moral virtues necessary for an ethical pandemic response and reopening (2020, June 26)
retrieved 27 June 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-06-moral-virtues-ethical-pandemic-response.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.



(Visited 4 times, 1 visits today)

Related posts:

South Africa re-imposes curfew as coronavirus infections spike
Crew members injured in fire on US Navy ship in California
Lebanon daily virus cases spike
Florida sets state record for daily Covid-19 infections
Florida reports 15,000 new virus cases in a day, a US record
Mali protest leader calls for calm after demonstrations turn deadly
Virus spread, not politics should guide schools, doctors say
Spain region orders lockdown as global infections gather pace
Polish presidential election results too close to call in exit polls
As virus rages in US, New York guards against another rise
France and Britain agree to form joint unit to fight migrant traffickers
Coronavirus Live Updates: Trump Wears Mask Publicly for First Time
France kicks off spectators' return to European football as PSG take on Le Havre
Global dengue prevention efforts stifled by coronavirus pandemic
Sudan allows non-Muslims to drink alcohol and bans female genital mutilation
Ubisoft senior staff leave over sexual misconduct probe at French gaming giant
Oromos say Ethiopia has become a ‘dangerous country for us’ at Paris rally
Inventor of Israel's Iron Dome seeks coronavirus 'game-changer'
US posts new daily virus case record of 66,528
‘Lives will be lost,’ warn aid groups as UN resolution leaves single Syria border crossing open
Dengue prevention efforts stifled by coronavirus pandemic
Trump finally wears face mask in public during hospital visit
Malian president dissolves constitutional court in a bid to calm deadly unrest
Poland votes in tight, high-stakes presidential run-off
Experts, advocates publish guidance for research on HIV, co-infections in pregnancy
Gender bias in evaluating surgical residency faculty members may be decreasing
COVID-19 can be transmitted in the womb, study reports
Age-related features of facial anatomy for increase safety during plastic surgery
Mom and baby share 'good bacteria' through breast milk
With social distancing, schools should be safe to reopen this fall, experts say
Why We Still Don’t Know Enough About Covid-19 and Pregnancy
U.S. sees another record-breaking day of new coronavirus cases
Widow of French bus driver beaten to death over masks says family is 'destroyed'
Five killed after gunmen storm a South African church, 40 people arrested
Coronavirus Live Updates: As U.S. Cases Rise, States Weigh New Restrictions
Physicians give first comprehensive review of COVID-19's effects outside the lung
LGBT rights at heart of Poland presidential-election fight
Study of Coronavirus in Pregnant Women Finds Striking Racial Differences
Coronavirus deaths take a long-expected turn for the worse
How Covid-19 can damage the brain
Malian anti-govt protests continue despite president's call for dialogue
How to Reopen Schools: What Science and Other Countries Teach Us
Virus cases up sharply in Africa, India as inequality stings
Study highlights multiple health risks among a people living longer with HIV
Jack Charlton, icon of English and Irish football alike, dies at 85
Couldn't socially distance? Blame your working memory
Is what I see, what I imagine? Study finds neural overlap between vision and imagination
Fury in France as protesters slam Macron’s choice of interior minister accused of rape
Abnormally high blood sugar linked with higher risk of death in COVID-19 patients not previously dia...
WHO urges aggressive virus measures as flare-ups spark new closures
US records 63,643 new virus cases in 24 hours
Bosnian Muslims mark 25th anniversary of Srebrenica massacre
Brazil surpasses 70,000 coronavirus deaths
Nano-radiomics unveils treatment effect on tumor microenvironment
Malian president urges calm in overnight address after protesters take state TV off air
Hong Kong opposition pushes ahead with primaries under shadow of security law
US bets on untested company to deliver COVID-19 vaccine
Trump commutes prison sentence of longtime friend Roger Stone
Serbia reports record daily virus death toll
Nearly half of US adults projected to be obese by 2030
Building surge ICU capacity during COVID-19
New research suggests failure to retrieve relevant details from memory may underlie face blindness
Study pinpoints brain cells that trigger sugar cravings and consumption
Cancer health disparities published in new volume
France virus death toll exceeds 30,000
Uzbekistan reimposes virus lockdown after new cases
The people tirelessly restoring Notre-Dame to its former glory
A Confederate flag spotted in the window of police barracks in Paris
Pandemic inspires framework for enhanced care in nursing homes
Mali protesters demand president's resignation over jihadist conflict, economy
They got a big ER bill because hospitals couldn't test for virus
Milde und schwere COVID-19-Erkrankung: Unterschiede der Immunreaktion gegen SARS-CoV-2
Instagram to block all content promoting LGBT ‘conversion therapy’
Serbia, Kosovo resume ‘very difficult’ talks on normalising ties
Coronavirus can still be brought under control: WHO
Kein erhöhtes Demenzrisiko durch Tiefe Hirnstimulation
Balloons bring internet to Kenya's rural Rift Valley
How do COVID-19 antibody tests differ from diagnostic tests?
Virtueller DIVI-Kongress als Novum für 6.000 Teilnehmer
Decades on, 'hidden children' forced into orphanages of colonial France remain traumatised
Macron revamps cabinet, France rules out new lockdown and Louvre reopens
Fat cell hormone boosts potential of stem cell therapy
Neue Studie von UKE-Forschenden: SARS-CoV-2 befällt auch das Herz
UK travellers hope to salvage holidays as government eases quarantine rules
WHO special envoy on Covid-19 'extremely worried' about rise in cases worldwide
Sutter Health’s Request to Delay $575 Million Settlement Is Denied
Florida's curve no longer flat amid new surge of virus cases
DGK für Engagement in der Corona-Krise ausgezeichnet
Turkish court paves way to reconverting Hagia Sophia museum into a mosque
Netherlands takes Russia to European court over 2014 downing of Flight MH17
Coronavirus Live Updates: U.S. Nears 60,000 New Daily Cases
Largest study of prostate cancer genomics in Black Americans IDs targets for therapies
Medienpreis Urologie für fundierte Berichterstattung im Zeitalter von Dr. Google
Teletherapy, Popular in the Pandemic, May Outlast It
Ozone disinfection could safely allow reuse of personal protective equipment
COVID-19-Pandemie: Mehr Fälle des Brocken-Heart-Syndroms
The many lives of Hagia Sophia, Istanbul’s ‘wonder of wonders’
Meet the Heroes Fighting on the Front Lines Against Covid-19
How COVID-19 lockdown has impacted people with arthritis
Intensivmedizin an der Universitätsmedizin Göttingen wird erweitert

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *