We can’t (and shouldn’t) expect clinicians without PPE to treat COVID-19 patients

Credit: CC0 Public Domain

We can’t, and shouldn’t, expect healthcare professionals without adequate personal protective equipment (PPE) to risk their lives to care for patients with COVID-19 infection, contends an expert in a stinging rebuke, published in the Journal of Medical Ethics.

Governments in the developed world knew full well what they were doing when they chose to underfund health service infrastructure and ignore repeated warnings about the advent of a pandemic, such as SARS-CoV2, the coronavirus responsible for COVID-19 infection.

And so did we, by voting for them, claims Dr. Udo Schuklenk, of Queen’s University, Kingston, Ontario, Canada. We’ve only got ourselves to blame.

Many healthcare workers across the globe have resigned, staged protests, or gone on strike over the lack of PPE. Hundreds have already lost their lives while on the frontline of COVID-19 care.

And “there can be no doubt that the among caring for COVID-19 patients all over the world will be significant,” warns the author.

Amid rising concerns about the human cost of inadequate PPE supplies, some governments have considered introducing a compulsory service obligation for healthcare professionals as they grapple with the issue of whether clinicians have a professional duty of care “under the circumstances,” points out Dr. Schuklenk.

“During the early days of the HIV pandemic, when an infection with that virus meant certain death, in most countries eventually decreed that healthcare professionals had an obligation to treat,” he explains.

The risk of death from COVID-19 is lower, but what makes it different is that the regulatory response was predicated on the availability of PPE. “With SARS-CoV2, we are, in most countries, in a very different situation,” he insists.

Taxpayers in many countries in the global north that have some form of publicly funded healthcare have voted for governments that favoured low tax regimes and austerity measures, effectively crippling services, he says.

“The endpoint was the same: democratically elected governments across the global north have left hospitals woefully unprepared for the onslaught of patients, not only in terms of ICU beds and ventilators, but also in terms of PPE,” he writes.

“The unavailability of PPE to efficiently maintain universal precautions while on the job was a foreseeable consequence of the race to the public services bottom that globalisation motivates,” he contends.

“It’s not as if governments and their experts did not know that the occurrence of an agent like SARS-CoV2 or worse was likely,” he points out, adding that there’s no excuse for the shortage of PPE.

“[It] does not constitute hi-tech expensive equipment; all of it can be produced relatively cheaply, and it can be stored in large quantities without taxing a given healthcare system unreasonably financially,” he writes.

Except that now, of course, it is much more expensive, because no one prepared properly and invested in it when it was readily available.

“We live in democracies, and we elected politicians who promised us time and again that we could have our cake and eat it. It turns out, unsurprisingly, we cannot have that,” he points out.

“There is no reason why doctors, nurses, and other healthcare workers should be seen to be professionally obliged to risk their wellbeing during pandemic outbreaks in the global north, because we chose governments that starved the delivery infrastructure sufficiently of resources to permit them to do their job safely or with minimal increases to their average on-the-job risk,” he concludes. “Elections have consequences.”

Editorial paper finds COVID-19 death among doctors in the UK is mostly in over-60s

More information:
What healthcare professionals owe us: why their duty to treat during a pandemic is contingent on personal protective equipment (PPE), Journal of Medical Ethics (2020). jme.bmj.com/lookup/doi/10.1136 … edethics-2020-106278

We can’t (and shouldn’t) expect clinicians without PPE to treat COVID-19 patients (2020, May 21)
retrieved 21 May 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-05-shouldnt-clinicians-ppe-covid-patients.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.


Related posts:

Lidar used to track mosquito activity in Africa to help combat malaria
US health officials quietly release more reopening guidance
Erfolgreicher Sonderforschungsbereich zu Hepatitis-Viren und Immunabwehr
France virus intenstive care patients drop below 2,000
Den Immunzellen in Hirntumoren auf der Spur
Up to 60% of students in some schools vaped in past month
US records 1,225 coronavirus deaths in 24 hours: Johns Hopkins
Researchers urge clinical trial of blood pressure drug to prevent complication of COVID-19
Faktencheck: Augenherpes wegen Mundschutz? Zusammenhang nicht belegt
Anti-malarial drug shows promise for brain cancer treatment
Studie enthüllt viele Möglichkeiten, wie Karzinogene die Entwicklung von Brustkrebs auslösen
Hamster tests show masks reduce coronavirus spread: scientists
Psoriasis und Psoriasis-Arthritis: Evaluierung veränderbarer Risikofaktoren
COVID-19 and people with disabilities
Electronic health records fail to detect up to 33% of medication errors
Plan in place to increase production of prefilled syringes for future COVID-19 vaccine
SARS-CoV-2-PCR-Tests erreichen Rekordniveau – Zahl der Antikörpertests steigt
Glucose levels linked to maternal mortality even in non-diabetic women
Cancer drugs cause large cells that resist treatment; scientist aims to stop it
Schnellere Identifikation von Krankheitserregern dank neuem Verfahren
Global study finds women less likely to have heart disease—and die of it—than men
New Zealand near eradication, but virus has grim global hold
Scientists fight online virus misinformation war
South Korea re-imposes some social restrictions to combat new virus outbreaks
Local climate unlikely to drive the early COVID-19 pandemic
Genetische Ursachen für die nicht-alkoholische Fettleber
What does recovery from COVID-19 look like?
Hilfe für Beatmungspatienten: Mit Salbe soll Sauerstoffaufnahme über die Haut erhöht werden
3-D-RoboticScope: Operieren mit einem Kopfnicken
Machine that oxygenates blood may help critically ill COVID-19 patients
Hebammenberuf wird beliebter - Biermann Medizin
Hospital response risks worsening health inequalities
Virus spread 'still accelerating' in Brazil, Peru, Chile: WHO regional office
Germany extends distancing rules to end of June
Europe's coronavirus cases top two million
Retinal texture could provide early biomarker of Alzheimer's disease
The cholera outbreak in a Victorian asylum that anticipated the coronavirus crisis in care homes
MEDucation TV: Medizinische Fortbildung digital
Regular aspirin use tied to lower risk for digestive tract cancers
Half of moms-to-be at risk of preeclampsia are missing out on preventive aspirin
DGIM-Vorsitz 2020/2021: Dresdner Gefäßmediziner Schellong übernimmt 
Newborn may have contracted coronavirus in the womb
New urine testing method holds promise for kidney stone sufferers
Officials release edited coronavirus reopening guidance
Biochemie-Absolvent der Universität Bayreuth hat Antigen für SARS-CoV-2-Antikörpertest entwickelt
IQWiG zu Ösophagus-Chirurgie: Mit der Fallzahl steigt die Qualität
Antarctica's splendid isolation keeps coronavirus at bay
High-quality end-of-life care will enable older people with frailty to live well and die well
Pregnant and lactating women with COVID-19: Scant clinical research
Coronavirus may never go away: WHO
Nierentransplantationen: Bessere Ergebnisse bei größeren Fallzahlen
Komplikationen nach Laryngektomie - Biermann Medizin
World coronavirus cases top 5.5 million
Schwangerschaft: "Natürlich" bedeutet nicht automatisch gesund
Endgültiges Aus für Mentholzigarette in der EU
Raumfahrt relevant für die Erforschung von Herz-Kreislauferkrankungen
Study highlights importance of emergency department in hospital readmissions
Iran says virus deaths close to 7,000
Klappenersatz bei Aortenstenose: Neue Erkenntnisse über den Behandlungserfolg von TAVI
Virus heads upriver in Brazil Amazon, sickens native people
DKOU 2020 abgesagt - Biermann Medizin
Gesucht: Hirnstruktur, die unser Verhalten steuert
Mental ill health 'substantial health concern' among police, finds international study
Preventing 'cytokine storm' may ease severe COVID-19 symptoms
Continuously active surface disinfectants may provide additional barrier against the spread of virus...
Pandemic halts vaccination for nearly 80 million children
Möglicher Übertragungsweg? Erstmals SARS-CoV-2 in Muttermilch nachgewiesen
A new potential target for the treatment of alcohol-withdrawal induced depression
Hemmung zelleigenen Enzyms: Strategie für Entwicklung antiviraler Breitbandwirkstoffe
Researchers develop high-performance cancer vaccine using novel microcapsules
COVID-19 patients who undergo surgery are at increased risk of postoperative death
Global spread of the multi-resistant pathogen Stenotrophomonas maltophilia
New studies reveal extent and risks of laughing gas and stimulant abuse among young people
Study finds that aging neurons accumulate DNA damage
'Reborn' Swiss to drop most virus restrictions on June 6
Das Spülschwamm-Mikrobiom: Was dich nicht umbringt, macht dich härter!
Neue Angiographie-Einheit erweitert Behandlungsmöglichkeiten deutlich
Palliative care for heart failure patients may lower rehospitalization risk and improve outcomes
Woche des Sehens 2020: "Die Zukunft im Auge behalten"
Examining the impact of major life events on wellbeing
Russia's virus spread stabilising: top health official
Nicht immer lässt sich SARS-CoV-2 über einen Abstrich nachweisen
'Hug glove' gives Canada family bit of normalcy in pandemic
Donating blood to get back to work during COVID-19
Continuously tracking fear response could improve mental health treatment
SARS-CoV-2 verstehen: Forschungsprojekte ergründen Eigenschaften und Ausbreitung
SARS-CoV-2 geht an die Nieren – welche therapeutischen Konsequenzen sind zu ziehen?
Sehen ist ein Entscheidungsprozess - Biermann Medizin
'Time is vision' after a stroke
When could a COVID-19 vaccine be ready?
Study reveals 'extensive' financial links between leaders of US medical societies and industry
Moleküle in Zellen zerstörungsfrei analysieren
Wearing face masks at home might help ward off COVID-19 spread among family members
Americans and Europeans soak up the sun amid new rules
Ärzte-Statistik: 402.000 Ärzte in Deutschland
STAAB-Studie: Mehr als die Hälfte der Probanden haben Vorstufe einer Herzinsuffizienz
DKFZ: Drei Maßnahmen könnten eine Million Krebsfälle vermeiden
Lagerungsschwindel – Einfache Frage zur Diagnose?
Analyse: Frauen viel häufiger wegen Krebs berufsunfähig als Männer
Research probes why COVID-19 seems to spare young children

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Multi-drug regimen for heart failure could meaningfully extend patients' lives

Fri May 22 , 2020
Credit: CC0 Public Domain Patients with heart failure have substantially shorter life expectancies than people without this condition. Approximately 6.5 million people in the U.S. and over 64 million people worldwide have heart failure, and about half of them have heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF). In the last […]