Why don’t we hear about the low number of coronavirus deaths in Central Europe?


Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

While the English language media gushes over how successful New Zealand has been in dealing with the coronavirus pandemic, it has largely failed to report on another part of the world where both infection rates and fatalities remain low.

Significant success stories in Central Europe are being overlooked. Slovakia, home to 5 million people, has so far had only 28 COVID-19 deaths and only 1,607 infections. That’s five deaths per million inhabitants—New Zealand has had four per million inhabitants. The UK has had 628 deaths per million inhabitants, Spain 606, Italy 573 and France 455.

The statistics in some of the other Central European countries have been just as stunning. Croatia has had 26 deaths per million inhabitants, the Czech Republic 32 and Poland 37.

New Zealand has been consistently praised for its “swift and stringent lockdown” approach. The English speaking media is concentrating almost exclusively on the highly successful “test and trace” policy of New Zealand, which made it possible for that country to declare, perhaps slightly prematurely, the end of the pandemic on June 8.

But the Central European countries also quickly implemented the same approach extremely early. For instance, the Czech Republic imposed a total lockdown on March 15, when there were just 293 infections in the country.. On March 18 it ordered the population to wear masks. Testing has been freely available from the very beginning, international travel suspended, and travelers requested to self-isolate for 14 days.

In Croatia, the government daily briefing includes detailed information on the national test, trace and isolate strategy. The public is informed about the exact locations of positive cases, how many people were tested and how many contacts were placed in isolation as a result. This has been happening since the first patient was tracked at the end of February. Like New Zealand, Croatia also announced reaching zero cases on June 11. Some local outbreaks followed, but the death rate remains low.

But in the English-language media, Central European success has been notably under reported. When it has been the subject of coverage, some long-circulating cultural and geopolitical tropes are evident. Stereotypes about the history of Central Europe continue to shape how the region is viewed by the rest of the world. It is regularly depicted as suffering from continuous hardship and as being blighted by authoritarianism.

For example the headline of a recent New York Times article described how “Europe’s battle-hardened nations show resilience in virus fight” and explained how Croatia managed the pandemic successfully because of “tough recent experiences of war”.

References to wars (in Croatia’s case the 1990s War of Independence) are not a novelty in reporting COVID-19. But characterizing Croatia as being defined by a war that ended a long time ago is one dimensional and patronizing.

Xenophobic clichés

Central Europe is written about as though it is a region in a permanent state of crisis. That has been particularly jarring at a time when the whole world is in a state of crisis, and these countries actually seem to be handling it better than many others. The stereotypes the New York Times article enlists, such as the region’s experience of traumatic events, hardship, and passive suffering, are all too well known to scholars of the area.

Instead of focusing on themes of collective suffering, perhaps more media should look more closely at the public health systems in operation in Central Europe. Early research indicates these nations should be credited for a successful response to the pandemic.

Another kind of cultural stereotyping is at play too—that people in Central Europe are xenophobic. A recent article on Euroactiv Fondation argues that in those countries citizens are more “disciplined” and have taken on the virus in the same manner in which they “have staunchly opposed migration, as if the ‘aliens’ would destroy their societies in the manner of science-fiction movies. Eastern Europeans, in general, fail to understand the Western laissez-faire”.

It is never suggested that New Zealand introduced strict border closures because of some kind of innate underlying racism. But in general has a tendency to feed into an overall negative image of Eastern Europe as being guilty of precisely that.

Historical distortions have been playing a prominent role in reporting the crisis. It is a shame that there seems to be so little information about what is really happening in Eastern Europe at a moment when every nation is looking to learn from each other’s successes and failures in dealing with this shared crisis. For this reason we need more coverage in English language media of what has happened in Central Europe.

Follow the latest news on the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak

Provided by
The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.The Conversation

Why don’t we hear about the low number of coronavirus deaths in Central Europe? (2020, June 26)
retrieved 27 June 2020
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-06-dont-coronavirus-deaths-central-europe.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

(Visited 4 times, 1 visits today)

Related posts:

Russia announces virus deaths exceed 10,000
Hong Kong libraries pull books by territory’s pro-democracy activists in wake of China security law
The Pandemic’s Big Mystery: How Deadly Is the Coronavirus?
Mexico reverses some openings as virus cases continue high
Area C, the chunk of the West Bank the Israeli right has long coveted
Dog in Georgia tests positive for virus that causes COVID-19
Pubs open, gyms shut: England's health dilemma
China plans reforms to organ donation rules
Covid 19: Making the poor poorer
Catalonia places 200,000 people under new lockdown following Covid-19 surge
US marks record 57,683 new COVID-19 cases in 24 hours: tracker
As much of US marks a muted Independence Day, Trump encourages big parties
WHO says first alerted to virus by its office, not China
Paris's Louvre reopens on Monday after lockdown losses of 'over €40 million'
How coronavirus self-isolation fatigue may lead to more beach drownings this summer
what's the new coronavirus saliva test, and how does it work?
The WHO's risky communication strategy created confusion around COVID-19
England's pubs, restaurants and hairdressers reopen as COVID-19 lockdown eases
French jihadist sentenced to 30 years for IS group executions in Syria
We looked at the health star rating of 20,000 foods and this is what we found
Trump rallies against anti-racism protesters seeking to 'defame' heroes
The US has bought most of the world's remdesivir. Here's what it means for the rest of us
Antibodies against phosphorylcholine give protection against rheumatic systemic disease
Researchers determine how much oxygen the brain needs
Britain eases virus quarantine as US under siege
Researchers find fans of apocalyptic movies may be coping with pandemic better
Some say allow family access to dying patients with COVID-19
11 of Our Best Weekend Reads
China aims to phase out sale of live poultry at food markets
U.S. Coronavirus Cases Are Rising Sharply, but Deaths Are Still Down
Spain counts 17 new virus deaths in 24 hours
At least thirty villagers massacred in central Mali terror attacks
Point-prevalence surveys in SNFs help cut COVID-19 transmission
Saudi Arabia passes 200,000 virus cases
French court opens inquiry into former PM Philippe in handling of Covid crisis
Protective antibodies identified for rare, polio-like disease in children
Air France to cut 7,580 jobs at French flagship carrier and regional unit Hop!
New French PM Castex says priority to meet Covid-19 pandemic, economic crisis as he takes helm
'Data not lying', WHO urges countries to 'wake up' and halt virus
Prosecutors seek life term for French jihadist accused of Syria executions
Mystery of hundreds of elephants found dead in Botswana
Injuries shoot up after fireworks laws loosened in West Virginia
‘We can’t afford an ounce of meat’: Economic crisis strangles Lebanon
Algeria welcomes remains of fighters against colonisation from France
Neurological symptoms described in children with COVID-19
United States: In Louisiana, Cajuns are keen to preserve their identity
HIV may not worsen COVID-19 outlook
250. Split-Lebertransplantation am UKR - Biermann Medizin
Live Coronavirus Updates: U.S. Leaders Change Course
EU authorises use of remdesivir to treat coronavirus
Turkey challenges allies and enemies alike in quest for ‘larger role on world stage’
Porres neuer Chefarzt in Leverkusen
Even gut immune response is site-specific
Systemische Therapie kann jetzt mit den Krankenkassen abgerechnet werden
Inflammatory Bowel Disease Tied to Increased Dementia Risk
Macron names Jean Castex as new French prime minister
Popular chemotherapy drug may be less effective in overweight and obese women
Studie: Junge Menschen rauchen und trinken weniger
Can an Algorithm Predict the Pandemic’s Next Moves?
Death toll climbs to more than 160 in Myanmar jade mine disaster
Israeli, UAE technology firms pen deal on virus research
Netanyahu's annexation plan, China's campaign against Uighurs and Hollywood before the censors
Uniklinik Köln: Augenheilkundliche Spezialbereiche jetzt in Deutschlands größtem Krebs-Ambulatorium
Dutch report new coronavirus infection on mink farm
Berufsverband will Weiterbildungsförderung auch für Urologen
French PM Édouard Philippe and his government resign as Macron prepares cabinet reshuffle
Florida under siege as pandemic accelerates
Japan asks US to extradite two men accused of helping ex-Nissan chief Ghosn escape
MB: EU-Ratspräsidentschaft als Chance für mehr Kooperation in Gesundheitsfragen nutzen
Monkeys infected with novel coronavirus developed short-term immunity
Das sichtbare Skelett 2.0 - Biermann Medizin
Peru surpasses 10,000 coronavirus deaths: health ministry
Herzreparatur mit der Gen-Schere - Biermann Medizin
UK to end quarantine for travelers from 'low-risk' countries
Turkish court opens trial of Saudi officials in killing of journalist Khashoggi
New study reveals how the brain organizes information about odors
French court to rule on reopening probe of former Rwandan president's assassination
Study could show why heart events increase seasonally
US Senate unanimously votes to approve draconian 'Hong Kong Autonomy Act'
US new single-day Covid-19 cases hit new worldwide record of over 55,000
Study says crowdsourced data could help map urban food deserts
Police in Europe arrest over 800 users of encrypted phone system used to plot crime
Artificial intelligence brings pancreatic cancer screening one step closer to reality
The Young Cut Loose in Myrtle Beach. The Virus Followed Them Home.
Study exposes disparities in health care access in rural Southern California
Florida State University Child Care Policy Draws Backlash
Surge in domestic child abuse during pandemic, reports specialist UK children's hospital
Live Coronavirus News: Updates and Video
Marijuana use while pregnant boosts risk of children's sleep problems
US sanctions against international court staff an act of ‘revenge’, says ICC’s Fatou Bensouda
New, more infectious strain of COVID-19 now dominates global cases of virus: study
‘We disinfect everything’: Amsterdam’s red-light district re-opens
France's Macron to embark on next phase of his presidency with ‘new team’
When Your Tween Is Bored
Why are more young people getting coronavirus?
Ideen-Wettbewerb: Woche des Sehens in Corona-Zeiten
French prosecutors seek trial for football star Karim Benzema over sextape scandal
Talking With Your Teen About Anti-Racism? Be Ready to Listen
COVID-19 death risk twice as high in New York City as some countries
Turkey demands apology from France over naval incident claim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Next Post

Buenos Aires to reimpose lockdown after rise in coronavirus cases

Sat Jun 27 , 2020
Issued on: 27/06/2020 – 13:44Modified: 27/06/2020 – 13:46 Argentina President Alberto Fernandez announced on Friday a toughening of lockdown measures in the capital Buenos Aires and its surrounding area as coronavirus cases are on the rise. “We’re going back to closing the Buenos Aires metropolitan area so that traffic dramatically […]